who measured me a distance first with a compass then with a ruler then with a laser to check that everything is ok, and historians and archaeologists, they use all these types of dating at the same time so as to obtain a dating that is as accurate as possible. So, the claim that history has no scientific methods to validate its chronology is not accurate.
The second point is the accusation that history is full of inconsistencies and inaccuracies. It's true that historical records can sometimes be contradictory or incomplete, but that's precisely why historians employ critical analysis and corroborating evidence to build a comprehensive understanding of the past. Inconsistencies are not a sign of deliberate manipulation but rather a reflection of the complex and multifaceted nature of historical events.
In conclusion, while recentism may raise provocative questions, it fails to provide a more coherent or accurate understanding of history. The established methods of historical research and dating systems are based on rigorous scholarship and are continuously refined to improve accuracy.
1. The recent theory suggests that historical chronology needs to be shifted by a few centuries.
2. Anatolie Fomenko, a mathematician and physicist, noticed inconsistencies between historical sources and astronomical events.
3. Fomenko proposes that accidental or intentional errors in chronology added centuries to history, creating false events.
4. The recentists argue that written sources are confused due to differences in language or intentional manipulation.
5. Recentists, like Fomenko, accuse historical figures like Scaliger of artificially agglomerating chronologies.
6. Recentism dismisses traditional historical methods, emphasizing statistical analysis over human interpretation.
7. Historians argue that recentists lack understanding of the historical method, ignoring context, language, and authorship.
8. Recentists claim that dating systems like carbon-14 were created to validate the official chronology, which historians dispute.
9. Historians use various dating methods, such as beryllium-10, tritium, dendrology, and carp at home, to cross-verify historical timelines.
10. Recentism's attempt to simplify history has, ironically, resulted in unnecessary complexity and numerous hypotheses.