Elizabeth, who grew up in a wealthy family in England, longed for a sibling. Her wish came true when her parents adopted James, an older boy from an orphanage. Despite initial tensions, they bonded quickly, especially after receiving a puppy named Caesar. However, James exhibited possessive and aggressive behavior, particularly towards Caesar.
At school, Elizabeth befriended Jay, a new student, and they developed a close relationship. However, James revealed that Jay was a thief who had stolen his father's watch in the orphanage. Despite Jay's denial, James' accusation led to a confrontation.
Elizabeth later discovered that Jay was poor and worked hard to support his sick mother. She confronted him about his lies, but he explained his reasons and she forgave him. Eventually, Elizabeth learned that James had indeed stolen the watch out of jealousy but planned to return it anonymously.
After reconciling with James and forgiving Jay for his deception, Elizabeth's family welcomed both boys back into their lives.
Here are the key facts extracted from the text:
1. The narrator, Elizabeth, was born into a wealthy family in England.
2. Elizabeth's parents adopted a child, James, from an orphanage when Elizabeth was 8 years old.
3. James was a year older than Elizabeth.
4. Elizabeth and James became close, and Elizabeth made sure James never felt left out.
5. James was possessive about the things he loved.
6. Elizabeth met a new boy, Jay, in her class, and they became friends.
7. Jay was handsome and popular, but Elizabeth found out he was lying about being rich.
8. Jay was actually poor and working as a waiter to support his mother.
9. Elizabeth's brother James accused Jay of being a thief and stealing his father's watch.
10. Elizabeth was torn between believing James and trusting Jay.
11. Elizabeth found out that Jay had indeed stolen James' watch when they were at the orphanage together.
12. Jay stole the watch because he was jealous of James having something from his real father.
13. Elizabeth was ashamed for not believing James and for exposing Jay's secrets.
14. Jay had been trying to locate James to return the watch and apologize.
15. Elizabeth and James forgave each other, and James came back home.
16. Jay apologized to Elizabeth and James, and they forgave him too.