The Mathematical Problem with Music, and How to Solve It - Summary

Summary

This is a possible concise summary:

The video explains the mathematical problem of tuning musical instruments, and some of the ways to solve it. It starts with the basic physics of sound and how frequency ratios determine musical intervals. It then introduces four main tuning systems: Pythagorean, Just Intonation, Meantone, and Equal Temperament, and compares their advantages and disadvantages. It also mentions some other tuning systems that are used in different musical traditions or by modern composers. The video uses audio examples and mathematical formulas to illustrate the concepts, and suggests that the choice of tuning affects the character and quality of music.

Facts

Here are the key facts from the text:

1. Sound is vibrations in air pressure, which are vibrations in the density of air molecules.
2. The rate at which sound vibrations hit the eardrums is called the frequency of the sound.
3. Frequency is measured in Hertz, which is the number of vibrations per second.
4. The frequency of musical tones is typically from about 50 Hertz to a few thousand Hertz.
5. All musical tones are made up of building blocks called "pure tones", which are tones that behave according to the mathematical function sine.
6. A tone with frequency f contains harmonics with frequencies 2f, 3f, 4f, etc.
7. The harmonics of a tone are called the first harmonic, the second harmonic, and so on.
8. In music, melodies are sequences of tones, one after the other.
9. An interval is the musical distance between two tones, and it is determined by the frequency ratio of the two tones.
10. The octave is a musical interval that corresponds to a frequency ratio of 2:1.
11. The frequency ratio between two tones determines how they sound together.
12. Pythagorean tuning is a system of tuning that uses exact 2:1 and 3:2 ratios, but not too many of them.
13. Just Intonation is a system of tuning that keeps some of the Pythagorean ratios, but replaces others with new ones.
14. Meantone temperament is a system of tuning that compromises a bit over the fifths, and slightly deviates from the exact 3:2 ratio.
15. Equal temperament is a system of tuning that divides the octave into 12 equal intervals, and is the most commonly used system today.
16. The 12 notes of the equal temperament can be laid out using the 12th root of 2.
17. The interval between any two adjacent notes in the equal temperament is called a semitone.
18. The fifth in the equal temperament is 2 to the power of 7/12, and is only about one tenth of a percent away from the exact 3:2 fifth.
19. The equal temperament allows perfect transposition of any melody from any key to any other key.
20. The equal temperament has some downsides, such as the fact that all intervals except for the octave are off relative to Just Intonation.
21. Some people today regret the loss of unique character in each key that was present in older temperaments.
22. Bach's "well-tempered clavier" was probably written for a temperament other than the equal temperament.
23. Microtonal intervals are used in some musical traditions, and can be accommodated by dividing the octave into a finer division than 12 equal intervals.
24. Some music theorists and composers have come up with other microtonal temperaments, dividing the octave into 19, 31, 41, or other numbers of equal intervals.