The story revolves around two childhood friends, Natalie and Caleb, who grow up in a town where the rich and the poor are at odds. Natalie's mother works hard to support the family, while Caleb's mother is a gardener for the wealthy Harrison family. The two children share a mutual dislike for the Harrisons and their lifestyle.
One day, Natalie and Caleb witness a humiliating scene at the Harrisons' mansion where a maid is scolded by Mrs. Harrison. Natalie and Caleb decide to teach the Harrisons a lesson by ruining their party. However, their plan backfires when Natalie accidentally falls into a food table, spreading manure everywhere. The Harrisons' daughter, Harper, and her friend Duke, witness the incident and start bullying Natalie.
In high school, Natalie and Caleb's relationship deepens, and they become a couple. However, their happiness is short-lived when Caleb's mother falls sick, forcing him to take more part-time jobs. Meanwhile, Duke starts to show interest in Natalie, leading to jealousy and tension between the two couples.
One day, Natalie accidentally destroys a town statue, leading to her arrest. Duke, the oldest child of the Harrisons, bails her out by paying a large fine. In return, Duke asks Natalie to pretend to be his girlfriend for a month. Natalie initially refuses, but after a heartfelt conversation with Caleb, she agrees to the deal. The story ends with Natalie and Caleb discussing their options to handle the situation.
1. The story is about two children, Natalie and Caleb, who grow up to be best friends.
2. Natalie and Caleb are from a poor family and they often express their dislike for rich and mean people, particularly the Harrisons.
3. Caleb's stepdad, Mr. Cross, is a gardener for the Harrisons.
4. Natalie and Caleb are both 11 years old when Mr. Cross starts working for the Harrisons.
5. The Harrisons have a daughter named Harper who is the same age as Natalie.
6. Natalie and Caleb become best friends and share their love for food.
7. One day, Natalie and Caleb witness a maid being humiliated by Mrs. Harrison, the lady of the mansion.
8. Natalie and Caleb decide to teach the Harrisons a lesson by spreading manure on their food table.
9. The Harrisons' party is ruined, and Natalie and Caleb flee the scene.
10. Natalie and Caleb become friends with each other and start dating in high school.
11. Caleb's mom falls sick and his stepdad's earnings aren't enough for her medicines, forcing Caleb to take more part-time jobs.
12. Mr. Harrison suggests that his son, Duke, should date Sheila Benjamin's daughter, who is visiting their town.
13. Natalie accidentally topples a horse statue in the town square, causing a commotion.
14. Duke pays a fine and damages to save Natalie from going to prison.
15. Duke proposes to Natalie to pretend to be his girlfriend for a month in exchange for the money he spent to save her.
16. Natalie agrees to Duke's proposal, but only if he agrees to a condition.