Nupur Sharma Controversy | Who was Right? | Freedom of Speech | Dhruv Rathee - Summary

Summary

The video discusses the controversy surrounding Nupur Sharma, a spokesperson for a political party in India, who made controversial remarks about Islam and Prophet Mohammed. This led to protests in various parts of India, including Jharkhand, West Bengal, and Uttar Pradesh, where the protests turned violent. The video also mentions the issue of the Gyanwapi Mosque, which was the actual cause of the controversy. The video then delves into the legal aspects of the situation, discussing the difference between hate speech and freedom of speech, and the implications of Section 295A of the Indian Penal Code. The video also mentions the case of Dr. Ratan Lal, an Associate Professor of History, who was arrested for making objectionable social media posts. The video concludes by discussing the potential consequences for Nupur Sharma and Naveen Kumar Jindal, another party member, and the broader implications of the controversy.

Facts

1. The Nupur Sharma controversy, which involved a spokesperson of a political party causing the boycott of Indian products in other countries, was the first time such a statement had led to this outcome.
2. Protests occurred in many places in India, with some turning violent, particularly in Jharkhand, West Bengal, and UP.
3. Stone-pelting and injuries to policemen occurred during the protests.
4. The police fired into the crowd, leading to the death of two people.
5. The controversy began with the issue of the Gyanwapi Mosque, which was ordered to be surveyed by the Varanasi Court in April.
6. An object was discovered in the mosque after the survey, which some people claimed was a Shivling, while others claimed it was a fountain.
7. The object was extensively discussed on social media, leading to jokes and mockery on platforms like Twitter.
8. The controversy was further escalated by Nupur Sharma's comments on Islam and Prophet Mohammed on various news programs.
9. The controversy led to the suspension of Nupur Sharma from the BJP party and the expulsion of Naveen Kumar Jindal.
10. The controversy resulted in 16 countries issuing statements against India, demanding an apology from the Indian government.
11. The Indian government went into damage control mode, stating that the tweets did not reflect the views of the Indian government and that they were by 'Fringe Elements'.
12. On June 8th, the Delhi Police registered 2 FIRs against Nupur Sharma and 31 other people, including AIMIM Chief Asaduddin Owaisi and controversial priest, Yati Narsinghananda.
13. The controversy led to the division of people's opinions into three categories: Honest Conservative people, Honest Liberal people, and Hypocrites.
14. The controversy led to the recommendation of an audiobook, "The God Delusion" by Richard Dawkins, which argues that there's no existence of God.