The controversy surrounds the alleged plagiarism in Kim Geon-hee's master's thesis at Sookmyung Women's University. Alumni professors conducted their own investigation, revealing that approximately 48% of the thesis contained plagiarism, including verbatim copying and unmarked content from existing papers. The university's conclusion on the matter has been delayed for more than half a year. Kookmin University also faced scrutiny for its handling of plagiarism allegations against Kim Geon-hee's doctoral thesis, with criticism of inconsistent standards. The academic community questions the justification for not considering certain instances as plagiarism and highlights potential double standards in the evaluation process. The controversy continues as the Ministry of Education seeks disclosure of data.
Here are the key facts extracted from the provided text:
**Document 1:**
1. Kim Geon-hee's master's thesis at Sookmyung Women's University was suspected of plagiarism.
2. Some alumni professors released verification results showing that 48% of the papers were plagiarized.
3. The conclusion of the university's verification process for the dental school was delayed.
4. Professors conducted their own investigation and made the results public.
5. Geometry was mentioned as inevitable in the university's verification process.
6. The university's verification results have not been published for more than half a year.
7. Plagiarized parts were found in Ms. Kim's thesis.
8. 48.1% of published plagiarism cases were calculated.
9. Four papers were used without citations and not included in the reference list.
10. The controversy has led to demands for disclosure and reinvestigation.
**Document 2:**
11. Kim Geon-hee's doctoral thesis at Kookmin University was questioned for similarities to existing research.
12. Similar content to other papers was found throughout her thesis.
13. There was no reference mark for the copied content.
14. Kookmin University's Research Ethics Committee concluded that there was no research misconduct.
15. Demands for disclosure and reinvestigation continued.
16. Kookmin University faced criticism for not disclosing transparent evidence.
17. Professor groups formed a self-verification group to verify Ms. Kim's thesis.
18. The Ministry of Education requested the disclosure of data.
**Document 3:**
19. Kim Kun-hee's doctoral thesis caused controversy due to plagiarism.
20. Digital content and sentences from academic journals were used without citation marks.
21. Kookmin University did not consider it plagiarism.
22. Criticisms arose regarding the inconsistency of standards.
23. The academic world criticized Kookmin University's conclusion.
24. The controversy remained unresolved about Kookmin University's justification.